The Tea Rose, by Jennifer Donnelly
Aug. 27th, 2012 09:42 amAt first I was not super into this book, but it's basically As The Crow Flies with a female main character. The writing style is even kind of Jeffrey Archer-esque. Fiona Finnegan's father is killed in a deliberate accident for being a union leader, her fiancé, Joe, is forced to marry his boss's daughter (Millie) when she date rapes him, and then her mother's killed by Jack the Ripper, her baby sister dies of illness, and her brother kills himself. So she goes to America, getting on the boat by pretending to be married to Nick Soames, her new awesome gay BFF, and that her remaining little brother is their son. Once she gets to New York, she takes over her drunk uncle's store and becomes set on becoming a tea merchant and ruining her ex-employer, the man who had her father killed. While I'm not a huge fan of it, I give Donnelly props for taking a typically masculine story and giving it an incredibly strong female protagonist and I'm going to finish it.
I really do try not to make a huge deal out of clothing descriptions in books, but I've been holding off on this one for a while and it's finally snapped my tiny mind.
( cut )
Look, I get what Donnelly's doing. I've outlined stories where it happens. She wants to show her heroine as doing her own thing and being fashion-forward and changing the prevailing style, and since we prefer more streamlined clothes it has to be fussy->plain. Lucile to Chanel. But if you want to do that, you have to set your story in the proper time period for her to be plausibly taken as fashion-forward and not a prostitute or complete weirdo by the other characters.
I really do try not to make a huge deal out of clothing descriptions in books, but I've been holding off on this one for a while and it's finally snapped my tiny mind.
( cut )
Look, I get what Donnelly's doing. I've outlined stories where it happens. She wants to show her heroine as doing her own thing and being fashion-forward and changing the prevailing style, and since we prefer more streamlined clothes it has to be fussy->plain. Lucile to Chanel. But if you want to do that, you have to set your story in the proper time period for her to be plausibly taken as fashion-forward and not a prostitute or complete weirdo by the other characters.