chocolatepot: Ed and Stede (Default)
The Antique & Artisan Show was a success! As far as I can tell without knowing how much money we brought in or having read the vendor comment cards - it just seemed like more people were buying. One told me that she felt our $4 admission fee was hampering sales, but IMO the issue is that her handspun yarn cost $38 per skein. I bought quite a few things for presents (and some for me), lost all the Silent Auction items I'd bid on, and purchased a $75 box of dozens and dozens of Needlecraft magazines dating from 1921 to 1940 - several years are complete and many are almost so. The dealer's been selling them out of the box for ages, $3 apiece/$7 for three, so it's been picked over some ... but it's still an amazing deal when you consider how much magazines with fashion info cost on eBay.

I recently discovered the Jane Austen + Text Posts Tumblr, which is a pretty great read. Her textual criticism is 100% fantastic, although sometimes I think her history is a bit less so, or at least ... it's not that it's bad, it's just that sometimes she states things very confidently and I'm like, do you know this because you read a text with references to primary sources on the subject or do you just Know This? However, she makes it all up to me with:

Pride & Prejudice - I know this one is one of the most divisive and contentious bits of Discourse ever to exist among nerds as there are just MORE to pick from and it’s the novel most people are familiar with. SO I will just say that I have Strong Opinions on all of them but for BEST it’s kind of picking from among adaptations which have all disappointed me in some way so I’ll say if you were to COMBINE the better elements of both the 1995 miniseries for timing and thoroughness with the 2005 feature film for artistry and visuals (and don’t come at me handwaving #aesthetic as though it’s not important, because that’s what cinema IS, and lighting/framing/visual cues are SO SO SO important when telling a story through film!) then you’d probably have something I’d feel comfortable calling The Best. On their own, neither truly satisfies me.

Know what? Fuck it, Bridget Jones’s Diary is my favourite adaptation of P&P. Bride & Prejudice is also very good. I saw it three times in theatres, including once by myself, and have no regrets whatsoever.


This is an opinion I respect. In honor of her I'm watching PPZ this morning - I could rant on about worldbuilding issues, but tbh what I think is most disappointing is the way that Elizabeth is 99% a different character than in canon, yet they don't seem to believe that they lost anything in taking her from "a witty, self-assured young woman who likes a laugh" to "she's the MODERN Austen heroine, if you don't like it, DEAL".

I am liking this new season of Who. The premiere did nothing for me - not sure why - but Smile was great. I like Bill, she's well cast and well written.
chocolatepot: Ed and Stede (Default)
I was going to try to write, wasn't I? Ugh. Translating is much easier, might be doing that instead. I just don't feel the urge at all.

Hope I didn't make an ass of myself on Tumblr, but it does bother me when someone has clearly gotten pictures from my own blog and doesn't link back to the page. They're not actually mine, and I don't want to be pompously ordering people around by claiming academic cred, but ... it just seems wrong to me. I dunno, I can never evaluate myself well because I've always been a little obsessed with getting the credit I believe I deserve.

I wrote to SewVacDirect through Amazon to see about replacing my dress form - the guy said he'd check with his manager because it's been such a long time, almost a year, but since I haven't hurt it at all I'm hopeful. Although part of me wonders if they didn't just send me a large by mistake, and I don't actually need a small. If they won't replace it, I'm going to try to surgically fix it, because it's doing me no good the way it is now.

There was drama at work today! Someone I used to talk to - but sort of dropped off with because we had gone over all of our similarities and she never brought up any new topics - sat down and told me that we talked about what I'm interested in, but then when she brought up things she was interested in I shut down and gave her "disinterested vibes". I apologized because I know that I have a very flat effect, and unless I'm so excited that I'm animated my presentation tends to be low-energy, but she actually said no, that's not it. Bzuh? Melissa thinks she's somewhat jealous because I am animated with Sean and do a lot with him during the day - but it's silly of her, because the reason I do that is Sean asks me to walk to the cafe, etc. and comes up with all kinds of random conversation topics to distract himself during the day. So weird. And not only did she say all this despite the fact that I'm leaving there in a few weeks, she specifically said that she was telling me because I was leaving.

The whole thing made me really stressed and paranoid the rest of the day, so I'm not planning on adjusting my talking-to-her habits at all.

more Death Comes to Pemberley )
chocolatepot: Ed and Stede (Default)
A few days ago I bought this ebook, Bitch in a Bonnet: Reclaiming Jane Austen From the Stiffs, the Snobs, the Simps and the Saps, and my feelings are thus far SUPER, SUPER MIXED. Because on the one hand, there is a strong vibe of "sit down, ladies, and let a MAN tell you how Austen SHOULD be read!" But on the other hand, the actual words that are written on the page (so far) I completely agree with. There's little that's groundbreaking for me in the analysis (and I've heard he's really anti-Fanny Price), but ... it's just refreshing when people talk about Jane Austen as a satirist rather than a romance writer.
chocolatepot: Ed and Stede (Default)
My god, people, it's just alternate character interpretations, UNCLENCH. Honestly, I have never seen a fandom more hostile to for-the-sake-of-it ACIs and fun revisionism.

The first four of these rules for romance writing manage to nicely encapsulate why I don't really like romance novels anymore. I mean, look, it basically says "give your heroine and hero the same personalities and circumstances as all other heroines and heroes".

Awesome new blog I've discovered, by Beatrice Behlen from the Museum of London.

I keep forgetting to do this meme. From [personal profile] shaggydogstail:

-Comment with "Winter is Coming"
-I'll respond by asking you five questions so I can get to know you better.
-Update your journal with the answers to the questions.
-Include this explanation in the post and offer to ask other people questions. (If you want. Totally optional.)

1. What is your favourite recipe?
I think I would have to say the Butter Chicken from my Indian cookbook ... but I can't remember the title or the authors and it's not here with me. But it's creamy and delicious and if it didn't involve so much butter and cream I'd make it more often.

2. Top five book quotes.
1) "I can no longer listen in silence. I must speak to you by such means as are within my reach. You pierce my soul. I am half agony, half hope." - Persuasion

2) "If you want to know what a man’s like, take a good look at how he treats his inferiors, not his equals." - Goblet of Fire

3) I have to make the admission that I'm really bad at remembering lines.

3. What is your worst habit?
Picking. I get hormonal and stress acne and I can't stop messing with it (which always makes me more stressed). It sucks big time.

4. Tell us a joke.
This is the funniest Tumblr I have ever seen, which I determine counts.

5. You've run away to join the circus! What's your act?
They don't let me out in public, I stick sequins on the trapeze artists' leotards.
chocolatepot: Ed and Stede (Default)
No longer must the Darcys be confined to “three or four families in a country village”. This “little bit of ivory” has grown up and gone to London.

- review of 'Second Impressions', a P&P sequel

And there my interest dissipates.
chocolatepot: Ed and Stede (Default)
I know I promised a proper post back on Christmas, but that never really happened, did it. I've been in full-on thesis mode, writing a (crappy) conclusion and fixing my citations because there is something wrong with me and when I write I do these horrible, abbreviated citations - sometimes with most of the information there, sometimes with the initials of the book and a page number, sometimes with "find a source for this". For example, I indicated Fashion from Fashion Plates quite sensibly with "FtFP" and did not spend half an hour working it out yesterday.

I watched Kate Beckinsale's Emma for the first time while gathering the bottoms of my dress's sleeves and realized that I find Frank and Jane extremely interesting. I want to read a good book/fic about their relationship now. Sadly I don't remember Joan Aiken's as being that good. The secret correspondence, the arguments, the way he's a dick but she loves him anyway ...
chocolatepot: Ed and Stede (Default)
Hm, I might order this from the library based on the NYT review. Specifically:

"But little social credit can be expected from the brutal dispatch of an undistinguished captain of the infantry, without money or breeding to render him interesting."
...
The greatest pleasure of this novel is its unforced, effortless, effective voice. James hasn’t written in florid cod-­Regency whorls, the overblown language other mimics so often employ. Not infrequently, while reading Death Comes to Pemberley, one succumbs to the impression that it is Austen herself at the keyboard. When Lizzy observes her girlhood friend Charlotte Lucas deftly wrangling her pompous, tedious husband, Mr. Collins (whose hand Lizzy had spurned), her admiration for Charlotte’s artfulness could scarcely be improved upon by the woman who dreamed these characters up: "She consistently congratulated him on qualities he did not possess in the hope that, flattered by her praise and approval, he would acquire them."


It just sounds like it has Austen's edge that so many sequels/imitators lack. But at the same time the plot doesn't really grab me. Maybe after I finish the first Lymond book (YES I AM TRYING FOR THE THIRD TIME. I'm already twice as far as I was last time).
chocolatepot: Ed and Stede ([austen] sadface)
I just want to say, so I can get it out of my system and close out the tab, that this page has a picture that Austen seems to have identified as looking like Mrs. Bingley, and that picture shows a very cherubic, round face with a small nose and rosebud lips. I think Susannah Harker did a brilliant job as Jane, but no, in period she would not have been considered more beautiful than Jennifer Ehle.

Yes, this is about an anon fight I got into months ago.
chocolatepot: Ed and Stede ([austen] sadface)
Season 2 might have been "Glee's" highest-rated season yet, but showrunner Ryan Murphy has heard a lot of the criticisms about the season -- even from hardcore Gleeks -- and is ready to do something about it.

The creator of the hit Fox show has made his position on Season 3 quite clear: Few guest stars. Less songs.

Who made that criticism? Who was saying, "Oh, Glee is great, the only thing I'd change is take out some of the songs"?

So I put down The Watsons. Skipped to the end, saw that Emma ended up with an OMC, rolled my eyes. (Instead I'm reading When Beauty Tamed the beast, omg, [livejournal.com profile] tartanboxers, you were right, so amazing.) So now I will treat you to everything that annoyed me about Aiken's additions.

My irritation is probably OTT, but even badfic writers tend to stick to canon better )

ETA: Oh! Forgot the most annoying bit. In skimming through the rest of the book, I noticed to my horror that after vol. 1 of Mr. Watson's collected sermons is published (after being prepared by Emma, of course), Aiken totally used the bit from Austen's life with the Prince Regent ~giving permission~ for her to dedicate the next volume to him. And, you know, she did that in Eliza's Daughters, too, with Elinor writing Austen's novels. So much no.
chocolatepot: Ed and Stede (Default)
A Kiss Before Midnight, Eloisa James

Not as good as the others that I read in Mexico. It just felt like James wasn't trying. Maybe she was pushed into doing a fairy tale series by her publishers? Because this is the first book in a fairy tale series - this one is Cinderella, and the next is Beauty and the Beast. I didn't feel much of a connection to the characters, except maybe Victoria (the step-sister), who was beautiful and sweet and a little dim and nice to Kate. I didn't feel like Kate (heroine) had been that mistreated because it was hardly shown - step-mother Mariana was hardly in it. Part of what I like about Cinderella stories is the emotional release of the "oh, at last we can be together!" part, and I just didn't get it.

Interesting subversions: Victoria is actually Kate's illegitimate half-sister; the prince has an awesome illegitimate half-brother who is his right-hand man (and should have been the hero); the prince is poor; Kate was going to leave for London with her godmother, the awesome Lady Wrothe (who used the phrase "wardrobe malfunction" at one point and part of me was thinking, "that sounds SO wrong here," and part of me was, "hahaha, BRILLIANT") at the end anyway, which is an interesting subversion but also ruined the tension, imo; the prince was into archaeology and (anachronistically) proper ways of doing it.

Final score: don't bother.

The Watsons/Emma Watson, Jane Austen and Joan Aiken

I've only just started it but I may not finish. My god, Aiken, you not only can't write in Austen's style (which is very obvious when you go straight from the original chapters to hers) you can't pick up on all her characterization! It seemed pretty obvious to me from the beginning that Elizabeth wasn't as anti-Tom Musgrave as she pretended to be. And Aiken has a horrible habit of making everyone either dreadful and you want to kill them, or pure and perfect with everyone else being mean to them. FFS.

Profile

chocolatepot: Ed and Stede (Default)
Enchanted

May 2025

S M T W T F S
    123
45678910
11121314 151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Style Credit

Syndicate

RSS Atom
Page generated May. 30th, 2025 11:08 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags

Most Popular Tags